The Words

Droit à la déconnexion

French · 2017 · 2017
France passed a law making it legal for workers to stop answering emails after work hours, which meant that for every other country, answering emails after hours was still the unwritten expectation.

The Loi Travail, passed on August 8, 2016, and effective January 1, 2017, introduced the right to disconnect as part of a broader package of labor reforms. The provision requires companies with fifty or more employees to negotiate with employee representatives each year to define the terms under which workers can exercise their right to be unreachable outside working hours. The law does not ban after-hours email outright; instead, it mandates that companies establish clear boundaries and ensure that employees face no retaliation for respecting them.

The legislation responded to research documenting the erosion of boundaries between work and personal life in the digital age. A study cited during parliamentary debates found that 39 percent of French workers checked their email after 7 p.m., and 24 percent continued checking during vacations. Penalties for non-compliance can include fines of up to 3,750 euros and, in severe cases, imprisonment of up to one year. In 2024, the French Court of Cassation issued a ruling reinforcing the right, affirming that employers could not penalize employees for being unreachable outside negotiated hours.

The concept has spread beyond France. Italy passed similar legislation in 2017 as part of its smart working law. Spain followed in 2018. Belgium's right to disconnect took effect for public sector workers in 2022 and expanded to the private sector in 2023. The European Parliament passed a non-binding resolution in 2021 calling for an EU-wide right to disconnect. In Germany, the concept overlaps with the older cultural tradition of Feierabend, the boundary between work and personal life that German law reinforces through the Arbeitszeitgesetz, which guarantees eleven consecutive hours of rest between shifts.